Center On Executive Compensation
News

Anti-DEI Proposals Skyrocket – With Almost No Support

Published on:

Authors: Ani Huang

Topics:

Anti-DEI proposals actually overtook pro-DEI proposals among early filers this year, according to a new Fenwick analysisand have already surpassed last year’s total. However, their support among investors continues to be extremely low, begging the question of why they are used in the first place. 

By the numbers: Pro-DEI proposals have fallen in number compared to last year while anti-DEI proposals have blown up. However, the pro-DEI proposals still have higher levels of investor support, including several new ones this year. 

Pro-DEI Proposals: So far there have been about 25 proposals submitted, with a handful going to a vote. Importantly, every pro-DEI proposal so far has specifically addressed the company’s pull-back from DEI initiatives.  

  • Common topics include racial equity audits, reports on workforce demographics, pay gaps and the effectiveness of DEI efforts using quantitative metrics.  

  • New for 2025: three companies have received proposals requesting a report on research and analysis the board undertook before pulling back on DEI. 

Anti-DEI Proposals: These have skyrocketed to 54 so far, with the vast majority in the general category of reports on “risks of discrimination on the basis of political/religious views (average support typically in the 1-2% range). 

  • This year we also saw proposals for racial discrimination audits as well as outright demands to abolish DEI programs or departments (average support around 2%).  

Bottom line: It seems clear that anti-DEI proposals are less intended to influence shareholder support than they are a messaging tactic to pressure companies into making changes.  

A new DragonGC report provides a fascinating look into the Fortune 100’s experience over the past few years, including responses to shareholder proposals and changes made, and is worth a look. Their conclusion: “Companies are not jettisoning DEI but are recalibrating how it is presented in filings.”

MORE NEWS STORIES

What to Expect for Shareholder Engagement in 2025
Proxy Advisory Firms

What to Expect for Shareholder Engagement in 2025

March 21, 2025 | News
What’s All This About Schedule 13D?
Shareholder Viewpoints

What’s All This About Schedule 13D?

March 07, 2025 | News
Glass Lewis Holds the Line on Board Diversity Policies
ESG and Diversity & Inclusion

Glass Lewis Holds the Line on Board Diversity Policies

March 07, 2025 | News

Continue reading this content with the Center On Executive Compensation Membership package